SW potm AND fw potm

Should we do a potm for saltwater and one for freshwater? tell us what you think....

No bc that's one more thing to do Also more prizes must be givin.

If someone will supply the prizes I would nt mind running it.

KMX wrote:

No bc that's one more thing to do Also more prizes must be givin.

If someone will supply the prizes I would nt mind running it.

I will come up with some prizes and discuss them with you Kory, and I will run it. I might as well lol now that I have dont it I have a whole process for it. I dont mind.

dude these saltwater tanks people own on here are no joke i love freshwater but we stand no chance next to salt water

i don't think there has to be a prize other than forum recognition - have the potm as the pics on the side vs the random copywrighted pics - for me, that would be enough recognition as i don't want the kind of fish that are usually given away (no offense) and while $ is good, it is basically returning my membership fee and i'd rather kory have the funds to build the forum with sponsors who give us discounts - that's just my opinion

mabey it could be a once a year prize with all the monthly winners being finalists

thanks, red! awesome idea - a prize of some kind (s/be $ considering the distance of our members and the different tank setups) for the poty (pic of the year) displayed for the entire new year on the side

I agree no need for a price. I think one for sw and one for fw would be a good idea since you are getting so many photos to pic from.

Rachael0805 wrote:

KMX wrote:

No bc that's one more thing to do Also more prizes must be givin.

If someone will supply the prizes I would nt mind running it.

I will come up with some prizes and discuss them with you Kory, and I will run it. I might as well lol now that I have dont it I have a whole process for it. I dont mind.

That's fine. We need a prize for sure.

redstarflowerhorn wrote:

dude these saltwater tanks people own on here are no joke i love freshwater but we stand no chance next to salt water

SW pic has never won yet.

TanyaQ2000 wrote:

i don't think there has to be a prize other than forum recognition - have the potm as the pics on the side vs the random copywrighted pics - for me, that would be enough recognition as i don't want the kind of fish that are usually given away (no offense) and while $ is good, it is basically returning my membership fee and i'd rather kory have the funds to build the forum with sponsors who give us discounts - that's just my opinion

I totally agree with you but I don't think as many people would enter or vote if there is no prize. I don't mid having 2 POTM. Prizes are a must

TanyaQ2000 wrote:

i don't think there has to be a prize other than forum recognition - have the potm as the pics on the side vs the random copywrighted pics - for me, that would be enough recognition as i don't want the kind of fish that are usually given away (no offense) and while $ is good, it is basically returning my membership fee and i'd rather kory have the funds to build the forum with sponsors who give us discounts - that's just my opinion

, prizes are nice but bragging rights are alright to . but my opinion is yes there should be seperate, reason being is that slatwater entries dont seem to get many votes for POTM for one and this would be better for the saltyies IMHO, second if someone like me that only does saltwater and win what good would freshwater stuff do us?

maybe we could get some more sponsors and let the spopnsors dontate the POTM prizes that would be an awesome idea

lordraptor1 wrote:

TanyaQ2000 wrote:

i don't think there has to be a prize other than forum recognition - have the potm as the pics on the side vs the random copywrighted pics - for me, that would be enough recognition as i don't want the kind of fish that are usually given away (no offense) and while $ is good, it is basically returning my membership fee and i'd rather kory have the funds to build the forum with sponsors who give us discounts - that's just my opinion

, prizes are nice but bragging rights are alright to . but my opinion is yes there should be seperate, reason being is that slatwater entries dont seem to get many votes for POTM for one and this would be better for the saltyies IMHO, second if someone like me that only does saltwater and win what good would freshwater stuff do us?

maybe we could get some more sponsors and let the spopnsors dontate the POTM prizes that would be an awesome idea

Neptunes Cove?
Air Water Ice?
I'm working on it!

$20 Gift card to your local fish store would do anyone good FW or SW. The only prize that I have ever giving away that was FW was the BN pleco last month. I guess we need 2 POTM we are getting big!

kory IMHO gift cards to retailers are great idea especially if the winner gets to choose whether it be for fresh, salt, or the retailer has both

Very unwise two POTM would be! One POTM means only the best of the best pics make it in. We have enough of both to make it competitive. Don't take that away just because salt hasn't won yet. There are a few pics this month that might take it. Besides. What fun would it be if you can't pit fresh vs salt? That takes away from bragging rights!

i think a salt is going to win this month.

I agree witht he salt and fresh being seperated, but as one said, man some of these folks with saltwater.... I am salt and have seen some awefully nice freshwater setups on here. As for a prize, I have no preference to that. I think some would like the pat on the back and recognition, sometimes just a Nice Job should surfice.

keep em together its like a championship, saltwater people need to get better pictures :D

kory maybe we could get a potm tally under our names.


posts:132
points:143
location:egypt
favorite fish:tuna
potm wins: 2

i think that would be cool:)

We are doing one POTM for now. If that changes I will let everyone know.

thanks rachael u da best

lol I know............Tim, go into chat lol

where do we vote for this?

Voting for this month is closed. We have already named a winner. We vote from the 1st to the 15th. Voting for Feb potm will begin on Feb 1st.